Showing posts with label incentives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label incentives. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 15, 2020

Fun with numbers for January 15, 2020

Infinites make for math fun



Link: https://twitter.com/3blue1brown/status/1215087264792887296

I did as GS suggested and figured out the solution myself. (That's the point of following recreational math accounts, after all.)

It wasn't difficult, since the behavior of a function $ f_n(x) = x^{x^{x\ldots}}$ where there are $n-1$ exponentiations, when $n \rightarrow \infty$ is likely to be divergent for any $x>1$. This was my intuition, and based on that intuition, I assumed there couldn't exist $x$ and $y$ such that $f_{\infty}(x) = 2$ and $f_{\infty}(y) = 4$. Therefore the premise is false and the reasoning fails because of that.

But I didn't prove it. I did play around with a spreadsheet to check the behavior of the function around $x=1$, since $f_n(1) =1$ for all $n$ and the functions are continuous in $x$. A simple spreadsheet shows the behaviors for $x$ between 0 and 1 and for $x$ above 1. The rows are increasing $n$, the relevant part is the diff-in-diff column, a discrete version of a second derivative w.r.t. $n$:


What these results (and several others, the point of a spreadsheet model being to play around with the numbers, or as a responsible adult would say it "do sensitivity analysis") show is that for $0 < x <  1$ the function is increasing and "concave," therefore most likely converging to a number in the [0,1] interval; for numbers above 1, the function is increasing and "convex," therefore most likely diverging to infinity.

Still not a proof, but confidence is high. (And confirmed later by the rest of the thread.)

True to my origins as a Prolog (and Lisp, occasionally) programmer, I feel compelled to write a formal definition of this function, thusly:

$\qquad f_1(x) = x;$
$\qquad f_n(x) = x^{f_{n-1}(x)} \quad\text{for $n>1$} $

As usual, recursions FTW!




Go beyond one-step thinking to understand executive pay


Scott Manley, whose space videos are among the most informative on YouTube, expressed a common complaint about executive severance pay, on the occasion of Boeing's change of the guard:


My response is the précis of why you have to pay outgoing executives significant severance: it's a signal to the incoming executives, not a reward to the outgoing executives.

(This was particularly obvious in the case of PG&E in California, which paid a lot to its executives in what most people thought scandalous and well-informed people recognized as a move to retain talent under circumstances when most top managers were considering outside options.)

The responses to SM's tweet contained a lot of misconceptions about executive-level, also called C-suite, management, and this one, which was a response to my response illustrates the three most important ones:


(As I try to be more positive, I'll be anonymizing tweets that I'm critiquing.)




Yet another Rotten Tomatoes calculation (Doctor Who)



Given these numbers, it's

5,872,182,639,638,860,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000

times more likely that critics and audience use opposite criteria than the same criteria.





Never give up; never surrender!